Talk:Gnaiger 2019 MitoFit Preprints: Difference between revisions
From Bioblast
(Created page with "left|40px|link=http://www.bioblast.at/index.php/Bioblast:About|Bioblast wiki '''» MitoEAGLE preprint 2018-02-08''' == Phase 3: MitoEAGLE pre...") |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
'''» [[MitoEAGLE preprint 2018-02-08]]''' | '''» [[MitoEAGLE preprint 2018-02-08]]''' | ||
== Phase 3: [[MitoEAGLE preprint 2018-02-08]] == | == Phase 3: [[MitoEAGLE preprint 2018-02-08]] == | ||
* 2018-02-08 [[Gnaiger E]] Version 22 | * 2018-02-08 [[Gnaiger E]] Version 22. Change of title: '''Mitochondrial respiratory states and rates''': Building blocks of mitochondrial physiology. Part 1. | ||
* 2018-02-06 [[Gnaiger E]] Version 21: '''Note''': Subscript ‘§’ indicates throughout the text those parts, where ''potential differences'' provide a mathematically correct but physicochemically incomplete description and should be replaced by ''stoichiometric potential differences'' ([[Gnaiger 1993 Pure Appl Chem |Gnaiger 1993b]]). A unified concept on vectorial motive transformations and scalar chemical reactions will be derived elsewhere (Gnaiger, in prep.). Appreciation of the fundamental distinction between ''differences of potential'' versus ''differences of stoichiometric potential'' may be considered a key to critically evaluate the arguments presented in Section 3 on the protonmotive force. Since this discussion appears to be presently beyond the scope of a MitoEAGLE position statement, Section 3 will be removed from the [[MitoEAGLE preprint 2018-02-08 |next version]] and final manuscript. This section should become a topic of discussion within [[WG1 MitoEAGLE protocols, terminology, documentation |Working Group 1]] of the MitoEAGLE consortium, following a primary peer-reviewed publication of the concept of stoichiometric potential differences. | * 2018-02-06 [[Gnaiger E]] Version 21: '''Note''': Subscript ‘§’ indicates throughout the text those parts, where ''potential differences'' provide a mathematically correct but physicochemically incomplete description and should be replaced by ''stoichiometric potential differences'' ([[Gnaiger 1993 Pure Appl Chem |Gnaiger 1993b]]). A unified concept on vectorial motive transformations and scalar chemical reactions will be derived elsewhere (Gnaiger, in prep.). Appreciation of the fundamental distinction between ''differences of potential'' versus ''differences of stoichiometric potential'' may be considered a key to critically evaluate the arguments presented in Section 3 on the protonmotive force. Since this discussion appears to be presently beyond the scope of a MitoEAGLE position statement, Section 3 will be removed from the [[MitoEAGLE preprint 2018-02-08 |next version]] and final manuscript. This section should become a topic of discussion within [[WG1 MitoEAGLE protocols, terminology, documentation |Working Group 1]] of the MitoEAGLE consortium, following a primary peer-reviewed publication of the concept of stoichiometric potential differences. | ||
Revision as of 11:09, 8 February 2018
» MitoEAGLE preprint 2018-02-08
Phase 3: MitoEAGLE preprint 2018-02-08
- 2018-02-08 Gnaiger E Version 22. Change of title: Mitochondrial respiratory states and rates: Building blocks of mitochondrial physiology. Part 1.
- 2018-02-06 Gnaiger E Version 21: Note: Subscript ‘§’ indicates throughout the text those parts, where potential differences provide a mathematically correct but physicochemically incomplete description and should be replaced by stoichiometric potential differences (Gnaiger 1993b). A unified concept on vectorial motive transformations and scalar chemical reactions will be derived elsewhere (Gnaiger, in prep.). Appreciation of the fundamental distinction between differences of potential versus differences of stoichiometric potential may be considered a key to critically evaluate the arguments presented in Section 3 on the protonmotive force. Since this discussion appears to be presently beyond the scope of a MitoEAGLE position statement, Section 3 will be removed from the next version and final manuscript. This section should become a topic of discussion within Working Group 1 of the MitoEAGLE consortium, following a primary peer-reviewed publication of the concept of stoichiometric potential differences.
